Free Speech? Or Is It A Serious Threat?

Free Speech vs. True Threats: Knowing the Line

In the U.S., not all angry or offensive posts are illegal. People can rant, curse, or say ugly things online under the protection of free speech. But there’s a point where words stop being “just speech” and become a true threat—and that’s when law enforcement can step in.

When Words Cross the Line

Speech may be considered a true threat (not protected by the First Amendment) if:

• A specific person, group, or place is named.
• Details of violence are included (such as weapons, timing, or a plan).
• It calls on others to act violently.
• It is repeated and targeted, making someone reasonably fear for their safety.
• It shows serious intent, not just venting, sarcasm, or an obvious joke.

Key point: Courts look at context — would a reasonable person view the statement as a serious intent to commit violence?

Why It Matters

Think before you speak (type or post).

“True threats” are not protected speech. They can lead to arrest, criminal charges, and serious legal consequences.

What To Do If You See a Threat

1. Document it. Take screenshots and note the date/time and any relevant account names or URLs.
2. Evaluate carefully. Offensive or hateful words alone are not always a crime—make sure the post looks like a real, specific threat before escalating.
3. Contact authorities. If it meets the criteria for a true threat, report it to police or local authorities right away. Provide your documentation and explain why you think it’s credible.

.