Internet Information Police
Who Controls What You See Online? Unpacking Jeremy Godfrey’s Role
Claims that Jeremy Godfrey, head of Ireland’s Media Commission, “decides what you see on the Internet” have sparked debate. But how much influence does he really have? Let’s cut through the noise and clarify his role.
Who Is Jeremy Godfrey?
Jeremy Godfrey serves as the Executive Chairperson of CoimisiĆŗn na MeĆ”n, Ireland’s media regulator. Established under the Online Safety and Media Regulation Act 2022, this body oversees broadcasting, video-on-demand, and online content. Godfrey’s role includes enforcing the EU’s Digital Services Act (DSA) in Ireland, a key responsibility given that tech giants like Google, Meta, and TikTok have their European headquarters in Ireland.
What Does He Actually Do?
Godfrey’s commission ensures that major online platforms comply with EU regulations, focusing on issues like illegal content, disinformation, and harmful material (e.g., hate speech or terrorist content). Here’s the breakdown:
- Enforcing the DSA: The DSA requires platforms with over 45 million EU users to moderate content, assess risks to democracy, and be transparent. Ireland, hosting 13 of 19 “Very Large Online Platforms,” plays a big role, and Godfrey’s team oversees compliance.
- Targeted Actions: The commission can demand urgent content removal, like violent videos, and address disinformation, such as fake videos during the Israel-Hamas conflict.
- Collaboration: Godfrey works with the European Commission and other EU regulators, sharing responsibilities rather than acting alone.
Does He Control the Global Internet?
Not even close. While Godfrey’s role is significant in the EU, his influence is limited:
- Jurisdictional Limits: His authority applies to Ireland and the EU, not globally. The internet is governed by diverse laws across countries like the U.S. and China.
- Shared Power: The DSA’s enforcement involves multiple regulators, and platforms handle most content moderation themselves.
- Reactive Role: Godfrey’s team steps in for specific violations or complaints, not to dictate what’s visible online worldwide.
Claims of him being the “head of censorship” exaggerate his power. He enforces legal frameworks, not personal whims.
The Controversy
Critics argue that Godfrey’s focus on “misinformation” and foreign interference risks curbing free speech, especially during elections. Some call CoimisiĆŗn na MeĆ”n a “Ministry of Truth.” On the flip side, supporters say regulating harmful content is essential for public safety and democracy. The truth? Godfrey operates within strict legal boundaries, but the vague definition of “misinformation” fuels debate about overreach.
The Big Picture
Jeremy Godfrey wields influence over online content in the EU, thanks to Ireland’s role in hosting tech giants. But he’s no global internet czar. His work is collaborative, legally constrained, and focused on specific issues like illegal content. The internet’s decentralized nature makes it impossible for one person to control what you see online. Still, the balance between safety and free speech remains a hot topic—worthy of ongoing scrutiny.
Want to learn more? Check out the CoimisiĆŗn na MeĆ”n website or the EU’s DSA page for details.
Comments
Post a Comment