Bang Bang — I Should Have Cut My Hair

The Minneapolis School Shooting: Questions of Transparency and the Role of Gender Dysphoria in Robin Westman’s Tragedy

August 29, 2025

The recent mass shooting at Annunciation Catholic School in Minneapolis on August 27, 2025, where 23-year-old Robin Westman killed two children and injured 17 others before taking his own life, has left a community shattered and a nation grappling with uncomfortable questions. As details emerge, one issue stands out: the apparent reluctance to fully address Westman’s transgender identity and the potential role of gender dysphoria in their mental instability, as revealed in their chilling manifesto. While authorities and media focus on Westman’s obsession with violence and past mass shooters, there’s a growing suspicion among some that critical aspects of this case—particularly those tied to Westman’s gender identity—are being downplayed or obscured. This blog post dives into the evidence, the narrative, and why it feels like something is being hidden.

The Manifesto: A Cry of Distress and Identity Conflict

Robin Westman, born Robert Paul Westman, legally changed their name to Robin in 2020, with court documents noting they “identified as a female” at age 17. But in a handwritten journal shared on YouTube before the shooting, translated by the New York Post, Westman expressed profound regret and exhaustion with their transgender identity: “I am tired of being trans, I wish I never brain-washed myself,” they wrote. “I regret being trans.. I wish I was a girl I just know I cannot achieve that body with the technology we have today. I also can’t afford that.” Another entry revealed a conflicted relationship with gender expression: “I don’t want to dress girly all the time but I guess sometimes I really like it. I know I am not a woman but I definitely don’t feel like a man.”[](https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/us-news/robin-westman-transgender-key-details-on-minneapolis-school-shooters-mother-out-suspect-identified-as-female-101756319186522.html)[](https://time.com/7312882/minneapolis-shooter-robin-robert-westman-catholic-church-school-shooting-transgender/)

These statements point to a deep internal struggle, likely tied to gender dysphoria—the distress from a mismatch between one’s gender identity and biological sex. Westman’s writings also reveal severe depression, suicidal ideation, and a fixation on violence, including fantasies about killing children and admiration for mass shooters like Adam Lanza. While the manifesto is filled with hateful rhetoric—antisemitic slurs, “Free Palestine,” and “Kill Donald Trump” scrawled on weapons—it’s the raw expression of self-hatred and regret over being trans that has sparked questions about whether this aspect of Westman’s mental state is being sidelined.[](https://www.cnn.com/2025/08/28/us/journal-minneapolis-shooter-robin-westman-invs)

Social Media Scrubbing: Standard Protocol or Intentional Obfuscation?

One of the most frustrating aspects for those seeking answers is the rapid removal of Westman’s YouTube videos and social media content. The videos, which included a manifesto, displays of weapons with hateful messages, and a diagram of the church, were taken down shortly after the attack with FBI assistance. This aligns with common platform policies to prevent the spread of harmful content, as seen in cases like the 2019 Christchurch shooting, where platforms removed millions of copies of the shooter’s livestream. But the speed of this action, combined with the lack of public access to Westman’s digital footprint, fuels suspicion of a deliberate effort to hide details.[](https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/live/2025/aug/27/minneapolis-annunciation-catholic-school-shooting-news-updates)

Why does this matter? Westman’s videos and writings weren’t just evidence of their violent plans—they were a window into their mental state. The manifesto’s references to being “tired of being trans” and feeling “brain-washed” suggest gender dysphoria may have compounded their distress. Yet, with the content now inaccessible, the public is left relying on partial translations and media reports, which can feel selective. Minneapolis Police Chief Brian O’Hara has said authorities are analyzing “hundreds of pieces of evidence,” including these materials, but the lack of transparency leaves room for skepticism. Were these videos removed solely to prevent copycat attacks, or is there an effort to downplay the role of Westman’s gender identity struggles to avoid politicization?[](https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/authorities-seek-motive-in-videos-writings-of-shooter-who-killed-2-kids-at-minneapolis-church)

The Narrative: Downplaying Gender Dysphoria?

The official response has emphasized Westman’s obsession with mass shooters and lack of a clear motive. O’Hara noted Westman’s “deranged fascination” with figures like Adam Lanza and their intent to cause “as much terror, trauma, and carnage as possible” for personal notoriety. U.S. Attorney Joseph Thompson described Westman’s writings as showing “pure, indiscriminate hate” and an obsession with killing children. These are undeniable truths, given the manifesto’s content. But the relative silence on Westman’s explicit statements about regretting their trans identity is striking.[](https://abcnews.go.com/US/minnesota-school-shooting-suspect-robin-westman/story?id=125029777)[](https://www.bbc.com/news/live/cly22nkpz8gt)

Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey has actively pushed back against focusing on Westman’s transgender identity, stating, “Anybody who is using this as an opportunity to villainize our trans community or any other community out there has lost their sense of common humanity.” While Frey’s intent to prevent scapegoating is understandable, it risks sidelining a critical piece of the puzzle: Westman’s own words about their gender-related distress. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced a probe into whether gender-affirming care drugs played a role, but no evidence has surfaced that Westman was receiving such treatment. The absence of confirmed medical records leaves this as speculation, but the manifesto’s references to gender dysphoria-like struggles can’t be ignored.[](https://www.newsweek.com/maga-reaction-annunciation-school-shooter-transgender-2120436)

Some conservative voices, like Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene and influencer Laura Loomer, have seized on Westman’s identity to argue that transgender individuals are prone to violence, a claim not supported by data. Transgender people account for less than 0.1% of mass shootings since 2018, compared to their 1% share of the U.S. population over 13. Yet, dismissing Westman’s gender-related distress as irrelevant feels equally reductive. Their journal entries suggest a complex interplay of mental health issues—depression, self-hatred, and possibly untreated gender dysphoria—that may have fueled their descent into violence.[](https://www.newsweek.com/robin-westman-latest-transgender-mass-shooter-spark-national-debate-2120683)

Why It Feels Like a Cover-Up

1. Rapid Content Removal: The swift takedown of Westman’s YouTube channel, while standard for platforms, limits public scrutiny and fuels distrust. If the manifesto contained critical insights into Westman’s motives, why not release redacted versions to clarify the narrative?
2. Selective Reporting: Media outlets and officials have focused heavily on Westman’s violent obsessions and hateful rhetoric, but their gender identity struggles are often mentioned only in passing or framed as irrelevant. This creates a sense that certain details are being de-emphasized to avoid controversy.
3. Politicized Responses: Frey’s call to avoid “villainizing” the trans community, while well-intentioned, can feel like a preemptive shutdown of discussion about gender dysphoria’s role. Meanwhile, conservative claims of “trans-terrorism” exaggerate the issue, muddying the waters further.[](https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2025/08/28/after-minneapolis-shooting-trump-s-supporters-charge-trans-terrorism_6744797_4.html)
4. Lack of Prior Action: Westman had no criminal record or known mental health diagnoses, and their disturbing behavior—praising Hitler in grade school, writing in code—went unreported to authorities. This raises questions about missed warning signs, including those tied to their mental health and identity struggles.[](https://abcnews.go.com/US/minnesota-school-shooting-suspect-robin-westman/story?id=125029777)

The Bigger Picture

Westman’s case is a tragedy wrapped in complexity. Their manifesto reveals a tormented individual, haunted by depression, suicidal thoughts, and a desire to emulate mass shooters. Their regret over being trans and feelings of being “brain-washed” suggest gender dysphoria may have been a significant source of pain, whether or not they pursued gender-affirming care. Yet, the narrative around this shooting seems to avoid grappling with this aspect, focusing instead on safer ground: gun violence, mental illness broadly, or hate-filled rhetoric.

This selective focus risks missing a chance to understand the full scope of Westman’s motivations. Gender dysphoria, when untreated or unsupported, can exacerbate mental health issues, as studies show higher rates of depression and suicidality among transgender individuals facing stigma or lack of care. While there’s no evidence linking gender dysphoria directly to violent acts like this—transgender shooters are statistically rare—the personal distress Westman expressed can’t be dismissed as irrelevant. It’s possible their identity struggles were one thread in a tangled web of mental instability, alongside their violent fantasies and nihilistic worldview.

A Call for Transparency

If we’re to learn from this tragedy, we need more openness, not less. Authorities should release redacted portions of Westman’s manifesto to clarify their mental state and motives, including any role gender dysphoria played. The public deserves to know whether warning signs were missed—not to vilify any community, but to prevent future horrors. The rapid removal of Westman’s online content, while understandable, feeds suspicion that inconvenient truths are being buried. And while politicized narratives from both sides—whether decrying “trans-terrorism” or insisting gender is irrelevant—aren’t helping, ignoring Westman’s own words about their trans identity feels like a deliberate choice to obscure part of the story.

The Annunciation shooting is a heartbreaking reminder of the complexity of human pain and violence. Two children are dead, 17 others are injured, and a community is left reeling. We owe it to them to seek the full truth, even when it’s uncomfortable. Westman’s gender dysphoria, as expressed in their own words, was part of their torment. Let’s not shy away from that reality—or the hard questions it raises—while we mourn and work to prevent the next tragedy.

Sources: New York Post, Minneapolis Star Tribune, CNN, The Telegraph, Newsweek, Hindustan Times, Le Monde, TIME